Сегодня:
25 сентября 2020 года
пятница
Сейчас: 03:27
on-line: 36 зарегистрировано: 17618

Teacher seeks to dismiss sex assault charges over prosecutors' 'laziness'

  09.11.2015 03:47
Citing the "laziness" of prosecutors in presenting the case to the grand jury, a Maplewood teacher is seeking to dismiss charges she sexually assaulted six male students.

Nicole Dufault has filed a motion to dismiss her indictment, in part because she claims prosecutors did not instruct grand jurors on the law on Feb. 4, 2015, when they presented the facts to them to support the indictment.
 

Those legal instructions were provided to the grand jury about two months beforehand, according to a brief filed on Oct. 21 by Dufault's attorney, Timothy Smith.

"It doesn't matter that the State may have had many other grand jury cases to get through on February 4th. Defendant Dufault is entitled to a proper presentation in her case," the brief states.

"Her right to a fair and complete presentation may not be sacrificed by the State for the sake of shortening the State's day. The State's laziness requires the dismissal of this indictment."

In a statement, Essex County Chief Assistant Prosecutor Clara M. Rodriguez, who oversees the Special Victims Unit, said there was no basis to dismiss the indictment and said prosecutors will file a written response to the motion on Nov. 23.

"These are routine filings. As per the Court, we will file our reply brief on Nov. 23, responding to these claims. We do not believe there is any basis for dismissing the indictment. As such, we are moving forward with the case. However, we will provide a detailed response to Mr. Smith's brief later this month," said Rodriguez, who supervises Essex County Assistant Prosecutor Gina Iosim, who is handling the case.
 

A language arts teacher at Columbia High School, Dufault, 36, of Caldwell, is facing a 40-count indictment charging her with aggravated sexual assault and endangering the welfare of a child.

Dufault — a divorced mother of two young sons — is accused of engaging in sexual activity with the six students on multiple occasions between about July 2013 and August 2014. The alleged sex acts occurred in Dufault's classroom and in her car.

The students were between 14 and 15 years old at the time of the incidents, prosecutors said.

The evidence against Dufault allegedly includes a cell phone video of her performing oral sex on one student in her car, court documents state. The video was allegedly recorded by another student who was also present at the time, court documents state.

Smith, her attorney, has said Dufault suffers from frontal lobe syndrome, which he claims left her vulnerable to the students' "over-aggressive behavior." Dufault developed the syndrome after brain surgery she underwent following complications due to her first pregnancy, Smith said.

The grand jury handed down the indictment against Dufault on Feb. 11, 2015, court records show.

According to the brief filed by Smith, "the charges on the law as to the crimes set forth in the indictment were given to the grand jury on December 3, 2014." At the time, those charges were presented along with other charges, the brief states.

But when the facts were presented to the grand jury on Feb. 4, 2015, "no charge was given on the law," the brief states. The brief asserts it "defies common sense and experience" to expect the grand jury to recall the charges from two months beforehand.

"A willing suspension of disbelief may be necessary for the theatre and fiction, but it should play no part in assessing the adequacy of indictments," the brief states.
 

The brief notes that, at the end of the 132-page presentation on Feb. 4, grand jurors were asked whether there were any "additional questions with regard to the law."

But as for whether grand jurors understood the law, Dufault's attorneys asked Superior Court Judge Michael L. Ravin to consider "the intimidation factor, the exhaustion factor, the shyness factor, and sheer boredom factor" that would have affected the grand jury after such a presentation, the brief states.

The brief adds that "it would be absurd to conclude that the grand jurors must not have asked for additional law because they all recalled the charges they had been given two months ago."

In the brief, the attorneys also claim Dufault's charges should be dismissed, because grand jurors were not asked to consider any mental states in connection with any counts of the indictment.

The brief also states prosecutors provided improper instructions related to the second-degree child endangerment charges.

Those charges require evidence that Dufault had assumed responsibility for the care of the students, but prosecutors incorrectly suggested her status as a teacher was enough to satisfy that element, the brief states.

Earlier this year, Smith filed a motion to dismiss the child endangerment charges.

The judge rejected that motion and downgraded four of the charges from second- to third-degree crimes, because of differences in Dufault's alleged relationships with the students. Those four charges relate to two of the student.

Блог автора

Автор: budy   |  Green card, ART, Разное  |  26.02.2016 19:05  |  Комментарии (0)  |  Читать дальше
Танцующий обама
Танцующий обама
Президент Обама танцует с сестрой Аумой, президентом Кении Ухуру Кеньятой и другими на государственном ужине в Найроби 25 июля. (White House/Pete Souza) еще танцующих Обам?
Автор: budy   |  Наши, Green card  |  09.05.2016 21:21  |  Комментарии (0)  |  Читать дальше
Как я валил в Калифорнию
Как я валил в Калифорнию
После того как я неуспешно свалил в Германию, я вернулся в Израиль на прежнее место работы. Однако, не прошло и полгода, как компания решила закрыть израильский филиал и всех уволить. Несколько человек, тем не менее, получили предложение переехать в США (по L1), и начать работать в главном офисе фирмы в Южной Калифорнии.
Автор: budy   |  Foto, Чтиво, Health, Разное  |  28.06.2018 10:44  |  Комментарии (0)  |  Читать дальше
Еще один штат США признал Голодомор геноцидом
Еще один штат США признал Голодомор геноцидом
Огайо присоединился к признанию Голодомора в Украине 1932-1933 годов геноцидом украинского народа. Власти штата выдали соответствующую прокламацию.
Куда Pora _valitj и пора ли?
Куда Pora _valitj и пора ли?
История про то, как я ездил покорять Штаты, как я научился летать и вернулся домой. Куда меня завес ветер перемен. Много букафф под катом.


Топ блогеров
1
roman

  Всего постов: 128

  Просмотров: 43919


2
HelenGreen_USA

  Всего постов: 150

  Просмотров: 42690


3
Lola

  Всего постов: 142

  Просмотров: 42074


4
Volsebnik

  Всего постов: 169

  Просмотров: 35528


5
PavelGreen

  Всего постов: 153

  Просмотров: 33089


6
Taisia

  Всего постов: 84

  Просмотров: 27601


7
slim

  Всего постов: 40

  Просмотров: 24626


8
KarinaStar

  Всего постов: 24

  Просмотров: 23043


9
ded

  Всего постов: 120

  Просмотров: 17551


10
Andrey

  Всего постов: 43

  Просмотров: 16820


11
Divitych

  Всего постов: 74

  Просмотров: 16336


12
solooo

  Всего постов: 104

  Просмотров: 15873


13
Blood_pacient

  Всего постов: 69

  Просмотров: 14618


14
eva

  Всего постов: 117

  Просмотров: 14220


15
babene

  Всего постов: 97

  Просмотров: 14053


16
no_air

  Всего постов: 138

  Просмотров: 13590


17
geoleg1512

  Всего постов: 22

  Просмотров: 13447


18
piggy

  Всего постов: 128

  Просмотров: 12782


19
pozitiv

  Всего постов: 131

  Просмотров: 12347


20
NS

  Всего постов: 59

  Просмотров: 11875



Подписка на новости
Рекомендуйте нас